Combustible Dust Testing

Laboratory testing to quantify dust explosion & reactivity hazards

Flammable Gas & Vapor Testing

Laboratory testing to quantify explosion hazards for vapor and gas mixtures

Chemical Reactivity Testing

Laboratory testing to quantify reactive chemical hazards, including the possibility of material incompatibility, instability, and runaway chemical reactions

DIERS Methodology

Design emergency pressure relief systems to mitigate the consequences of unwanted chemical reactivity and account for two-phase flow using the right tools and methods

Deflagrations (Dust/Vapor/Gas)

Properly size pressure relief vents to protect your processes from dust, vapor, and gas explosions

Effluent Handling

Pressure relief sizing is just the first step and it is critical to safety handle the effluent discharge from an overpressure event

Thermal Stability

Safe storage or processing requires an understanding of the possible hazards associated with sensitivity to variations in temperature

UN-DOT

Classification of hazardous materials subject to shipping and storage regulations

Safety Data Sheets

Develop critical safety data for inclusion in SDS documents

Biological

Model transport of airborne virus aerosols to guide safe operations and ventilation upgrades

Radioactive

Model transport of contamination for source term and leak path factor analysis

Fire Analysis

Model transport of heat and smoke for fire analysis

Flammable or Toxic Gas

transport of flammable or toxic gas during a process upset

OSS consulting, adiabatic & reaction calorimetry and consulting

Onsite safety studies can help identify explosibility and chemical reaction hazards so that appropriate testing, simulations, or calculations are identified to support safe scale up

Mechanical, Piping, and Electrical

Engineering and testing to support safe plant operations and develop solutions to problems in heat transfer, fluid flow, electric power systems

Battery Safety

Testing to support safe design of batteries and electrical power backup facilities particularly to satisfy UL9540a ed.4

Hydrogen Safety

Testing and consulting on the explosion risks associated with devices and processes which use or produce hydrogen

Spent Fuel

Safety analysis for packaging, transport, and storage of spent nuclear fuel

Decommissioning, Decontamination and Remediation (DD&R)

Safety analysis to underpin decommissioning process at facilities which have produced or used radioactive nuclear materials

Laboratory Testing & Software Capabilities

Bespoke testing and modeling services to validate analysis of DD&R processes

Nuclear Overview

Our Nuclear Services Group is recognized for comprehensive evaluations to help commercial nuclear power plants operate efficiently and stay compliant.

Severe Accident Analysis and Risk Assessment

Expert analysis of possible risk and consequences from nuclear plant accidents

Thermal Hydraulics

Testing and analysis to ensure that critical equipment will operate under adverse environmental conditions

Environmental Qualification (EQ) and Equipment Survivability (ES)

Testing and analysis to ensure that critical equipment will operate under adverse environmental conditions

Laboratory Testing & Software Capabilities

Testing and modeling services to support resolution of emergent safety issues at a power plant

Adiabatic safety calorimeters (ARSST and VSP2)

Low thermal inertial adiabatic calorimeters specially designed to provide directly scalable data that are critical to safe process design

Other Lab Equipment (DSC/ARC supplies, CPA, C80, Super Stirrer)

Products and equipment for the process safety or process development laboratory

FERST

Software for emergency relief system design to ensure safe processing of reactive chemicals, including consideration of two-phase flow and runaway chemical reactions

FATE

Facility modeling software mechanistically tracks transport of heat, gasses, vapors, and aerosols for safety analysis of multi-room facilities

Blog

Our highly experienced team keeps you up-to-date on the latest process safety developments.

Process Safety Newsletter

Stay informed with our quarterly Process Safety Newsletters sharing topical articles and practical advice.

Resources

With over 40 years of industry expertise, we have a wealth of process safety knowledge to share.

Recent Posts

Mitigating Relief Valve Chatter Through Side Branches

Posted by The Fauske Team on 11.10.15

By: Jens Conzen, Director, Plant Services & Ken Kurko, Director, Process Safety Services Fauske & Associates, LLC

Chemical process plants must be protected from overpressure hazards. This is particularly important for reactive processes in which the pressure can rapidly build up if a runaway reaction were to occur. The overpressure protection is achieved by installing a relief device, which can be a rupture disk or a pressure relief valve. It is important that the relief device is properly sized to assure that adequate capacity is available to relieve the effluent. A common issue in the industry is chattering of direct spring operated safety relief valves (DSOSRVs) during the relief event. In a DSOSRV the valve closing force is provided by a spiral spring that is compressed by a screw. Once the fluid pressure at the inlet of the valve exceeds the pressure from the spring force the valve disc will lift, which opens a path for depressurization. The disc should fully lift to provide the nominal relief area if the valve is adequately sized. For oversized valves, the disc might lift only partially and essentially floats on the flow. The pressure feedback in the system will eventually cause an instability that can cause the valve disc to open and close rapidly resulting in flutter or chatter. The white noise generated at the valve trim may also contribute to the instability. Flutter is characterized by a high frequency oscillation of the valve disc where the disc does not fully open or close. Chatter is a more violent oscillation where the valve disc repeatedly slams into the valve seat. Chatter can result in valve damage. This can have dangerous consequences such as a stuck open safety valve that would result in the failure to contain hazardous materials, for example.

Since engineers have to be conservative during the sizing calculation (e.g. rounding up the relief area to the nearest commercial pipe size), it can be assumed that most relief valves are slightly oversized, and therefore, prone to valve chatter due to the starvation of capacity. Recent experimental research [1] has demonstrated that the frequency of chatter is dictated by the quarter wave frequency of the inlet pipe. The quarter wave is a standing wave that is defined by the geometry of the inlet pipe. It is an acoustic phenomenon that is analogous to an organ pipe. Figure 1 illustrates a schematic of a DSOSRV with the quarter wave.

Figure 1 Figure 1: 

A similar issue of SRV vibration has been observed in the nuclear industry. In a boiling water reactor (BWR) plant, SRVs are typically located along the main steam pipe. The steam that flows through the steam pipe can cause vortices at the leading edge of the SRV inlet pipe (or stand pipe) that would occur at a constant frequency. If the frequency of the vortex shedding coincides or is close to the quarter wave frequency of the inlet pipe, an acoustic resonance occurs. This has been observed in particular after power uprate programs where the steam flow velocity was increased. Although the excitation mechanisms are different when we compare the chemical process facility application with the nuclear plant application, the response is similar. Hence, one solution could work for both applications. Nuclear facilities have installed acoustic side branches (ASBs) to mitigate the resonance. It is hypothesized that an ASB installed at the inlet pipe of a DSOSRV could also have a stabilizing effect resulting in improved valve performance. Figure 2 illustrates an ASB that was installed in a nuclear power facility.

Figure 2: 

Figure 2: Source: http://www.intechopen.com/source/html/6732/media/image74.png

The acoustic aide branch consists of a piece of pipe that is capped with a blind flange. A removable canister that contains acoustic damping material is inserted into the ASB. The acoustic side branch has two major functions: 1) provide damping to reduce the amplitude of vibration and 2) to provide disturbance to disrupt the quarter wave. If designed correctly, it could also be used to generate an interference wave that could have a canceling effect on the quarter wave and provide further mitigation. Acoustic side branch technology is documented in US patent US 8393437B2 which is assigned to the Westinghouse Electric Company LLC, the owner of FAI. FAI is the acoustic testing laboratory for Westinghouse and FAI has been involved with the design and testing of ASBs.

FAI is currently performing proof-of-concept tests in our acoustic and thermal hydraulic laboratory. It is the objective to find out if acoustic side branches can be a viable option to improve relief valve stability for chemical plant applications. For more information, please contact Jens Conzen at conzen@fauske.com or 630-887-5203

References
[1] C.J. Hös et. al, Dynamic behavior of direct spring loaded pressure relief valves in gas service: Model development, measurements and instability mechanisms. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, Edition 31, 2014
[2] C.G. Moreno, Turbulence, Vibrations, Noise and Fluid Instabilities. Chapter 5 of Computational Fluid Dynamics (ISBN: 978-953-7619-59-6)

Emergency Relief Vent Sizing for Fire Emergencies Involving Liquid-Filled Atmospheric Storage Vessels

Subscribe to FAI's "Nuclear Technical Bulletins"

Subscribe to FAI's Quarterly "Process Safety News"  

Topics: chemical process, acoustic analysis, relief system, relief valve

cta-bg.jpg

Is My Dust Combustible?

A Flowchart To Help You Decide
Download Now